Misplaced
Priority and Its Social Impacts
2009-02-R15
(Copyrighted 2009
by Don M. Tow)
Salaries of Top-Level Professional Sports
The top 10 picks in last year's National
Football League (NFL) draft signed contracts that guaranteed an average of
$18.7 million over the lifetime of their contracts, usually four-to-six
years.[1]
This is the guaranteed amount; that means they could earn even more,
perhaps much more, if they perform to their billings.
The average salary per season in 2008 for Major League Baseball (MLB)
players was over $3M![2]
The average salary for the 2008-2009 season for the National
Basketball Association (NBA) players is $5.3M![3]
The average
earning of the 120 major-college football coaches in 2007 was over $1M![4]
Among the 65 colleges that made the
NCAA Basketball Tournament in 2006, at least 20 of those colleges’
basketball coaches were making over $1M for 2006-2007![5]
Salaries of
Top-Level Academics
How do the above salaries compare with the average salary of full
professors in doctoral-granting universities in the
If we compare the above salaries for professional athletes and
major-college football and basketball coaches with those for full professors
in doctoral-granting universities, it is clear that there is a huge gap.
What are the social implications of this huge gap?
This article discusses the social implications of this huge gap in
terms of the athletes themselves, our youths, ordinary citizens, and the
competitiveness of our country.
Salaries of
Professional Sports Just Below the Top Level
Before we discuss the social implications, there is another important set
of statistics that we also need to know, i.e., the salaries of athletes who
in every respect are excellent athletes but for one reason or another have
not yet made it to the top level of the professional hierarchy.
For example, there are various levels of minor league professional
baseball, with the highest minor league level being the AAA level, which is
just below MLB.
For a AAA
baseball player who has not reached playing in the Major League level yet,
his salary is usually only a few thousand dollars per month, with the
minimum being $2,150 per month,[7] although a
AAA baseball player who has played in the Major League but has been sent
down to the Minor League could be making significantly more.
Thus there is a huge drop in salary, as much as a factor of 50 to
100, from the Major League to AAA which is just one level below the Major
League.
Another example is the
Arena Football League (AFL), which is just one level below the NFL in the
Tremendous
Rewards and Pressure to Reach the Highest Professional Sports Level
The financial compensations of the top-notch athletes and coaches are so
phenomenally large, so that the earnings from one, two, or three years are
already more than most people can earn in a lifetime.
On the other hand, if an athlete does not make it to the highest
professional level, then there is a huge drop in salary, like a reduction of
at least by a factor of 10 and often by a factor of 100.
Furthermore, the amount of fame and endorsement money that they can
get is also strongly coupled to where they end up in the professional
hierarchy.
Under these
circumstances there are tremendous rewards and pressure on the athletes to
try to make it to the highest professional level or to the highest
performance in that professional level.
Is it then surprising that they may do anything, including taking
forbidden performance enhancing drugs, to try to get a competitive edge?
Thus we see so many top-notch athletes being exposed to have taken
illegal drugs to enhance their performance in baseball, football, track and
field, cycling, swimming, etc.[10]
This drive is often achieved with
single-mindedness so that they neglect their education, learning to get
along with other people including their teammates, learning to manage their
finances, and learning to survive successfully in the real world.
The end result is that so many of these athletes can not survive, and
definitely not thrive, in their post-athletic life in the real world.
Odds of Becoming
a NFL Player
Seeing the glamour and riches of the athletes who make it to the top of
their professional sport, many of our youths also aspire to be like them,
without understanding the tremendous odds against them.
For example, what are the
chances of becoming an NFL Player?
The answer to that question can be found
in the NFL
Players Association website’s FAQs:
“While many young people every year
set their goals on becoming NFL players, it is extremely difficult to reach
that level.
Statistically of the
100,000 high school seniors who play football every year, only 215 will ever
make an NFL roster.
That is
0.2%!
Even of the 9,000 players
that make it to the college level only 310 are invited to the NFL scouting
combine, the pool from which teams make their draft picks.
As you can see, most people who want to become NFL players will not.
Therefore it is very important to come up with alternative plans for
the future.”[11]
Similar odds also exist for other sports.
It is also important to know that the average playing time in
professional sports can be very short.
For example, the average length of an NFL career is only about three
and a half seasons!
Behavior Problems of Top-Level Professional
Athletes
Besides the tremendous odds against
youths becoming professional athletes at the highest level, there is the
issue whether these athletes are really good role models for our youths to
emulate when you consider the various social problems so many of these
professional athletes bring upon themselves.
There are many examples in almost every major professional sport.
Here are a few examples:
This list can go on and on for other
sports at the professional level as well at the top-tier college level.
Of course, there are many top-notch professional and college athletes
who are ethical, follow all the rules, and are great role models for the
youths.
But it seems that
the great disparity in recognition and financial rewards between the
champion and the runner-up, or the intensification of the winner take all
reward system, has created an environment that drives many athletes to be
willing to risk everything, including their ethics and their health, in
order to increase their chances of reaching the performance pinnacle.
Furthermore, these top athletes are
often so pampered that they never learned how to behave as decent human
beings after their limelight is over.
It
seems then that the current professional athletes are not good role models
for our youths to emulate.
Who Can Help Our Country Compete
Economically in a World of Global Competition? University professors are the people
teaching our youths the skills and intellectual creativity to drive our
economic engine so that we can compete successfully in the world of global
competition, which is especially important when the
Is It Simply Just
the Consequences of Supply and Demand? One may argue that the salaries of professional athletes are just the
consequences of supply and demand.
Their high salaries are just reflective of the fact that there are
great public interests for professional sports.
One may also hear that the large financial compensations for football and basketball coaches
are justified because a successful football or basketball program can help
student recruitment and alumni contributions. All of these actually point to
the underlying issue, i.e., has our society as a whole misplaced our
priorities?
Why should a school
kid who is a top-performing athlete gets much more recognition and press
coverage than a school kid who is a top-performing student in the classroom
or a student who is a leader in doing community activities?
Why should our media always put significantly more coverage on
negative-behaving events than positive-behaving events?[13]
We should understand that notoriety is also something that youths
want to emulate even if the events leading to notoriety are not something to
be proud of.
We know from sociology and child psychology that positive role models can
do wonders to young minds and negative role models can destroy young lives.
Doesn’t winning a Nobel Prize or other prestigious academic honors also help
with student recruitment and bring in research contracts?
Doesn’t achieving academic distinction also help with alumni
contributions?
Doesn’t achieving
academic breakthroughs results in positive impacts on our society?
Perhaps if our society has consistently emphasized and recognized the
activities and achievements that can impact our society in a positive way,
especially from a longer-term perspective, there will be a corresponding
change in the supply and demand equation.
Does It Impact
the Pocket Book of Ordinary Citizens? There is also the issue of whether the high salaries and endorsements of
professional athletes also financially affect ordinary citizens who do not
attend or watch these sporting events?
The answer is definitely yes for the following reasons.
The government at all levels usually subsidizes building sports
stadiums either directly or indirectly.
Direct subsidies include city, county, or state funds allocated as
part of the stadium building budget.
Indirect subsidies include various tax incentives, such as reduced
property tax from the local government and tax-exempt bonds issued by the
federal, state, and local governments.
These
government subsidies are funded by taxpayer dollars.
The local government also needs to spend money on various
infrastructure projects, such as building new sewers and roads, or public
transportation lines and stations.
Professional team owners want the media broadcasting
of their games to reach as many
people as possible to maximize the media broadcasting revenue.
For example, broadcasting certain professional team’s games may be
included as part of the basic cable package, which gives cable companies an
argument to raise the rate of the basic cable package.
This means that all subscribers of the basic cable package have to
pay the higher rate even if they don’t plan to watch any of that
professional team’s games.
New
stadiums are built not necessarily because the existing stadiums do not have
sufficient seat capacity or are in disrepair, but because the owners want
more and better luxury boxes which can bring in significant amount of
revenue.
Furthermore, unlike
gate receipts, a team does not have to share the revenue from luxury boxes
with the league and other teams; so 100% of the luxury box revenues remain
in the home team’s pocket.
There
is of course the counter argument that a professional sports team brings
people to the games and increases tax revenues for the local government, and
professional sports teams make a city more attractive for other businesses
to locate in that city.
There is
some validity to such a counter argument, but my guess is that if one does a
detailed analysis, the financial gains do not match the expenses, except for
the owners, the players, and businesses that are located in the vicinity of
the sports stadiums or are directly involved with those professional sports
teams. The real winners usually are the team owners and the players.
Both groups are already making a lot of money; so we are asking
ordinary citizens to use their tax dollars to make these rich people even
richer. There is also a cascading effect on the pocket of ordinary citizens,
independent of whether or not they watch the professional sports.
Televisions and various sponsors, such as companies who make
sneakers, apparel, various foods and drinks, and many other products being
pitched by these high-paying athletes, all raise the prices of their products
in order to pay for the high endorsements received by the athletes.
Thus even old ladies in tennis shoes who never watch any of the
sporting events share in paying these professional athletes and coaches the
phenomenal salaries they are now receiving.
Summary There is great disparity between the salaries of top professional
athletes/coaches and people in other professions, including top-notch
academics.
The chances of
becoming a major league professional athlete are extremely small, and the
salaries of professional athletes just one level below the major
professional leagues, together with the corresponding recognition and
endorsement revenue, are no
longer large, and perhaps non-existent for endorsement revenue. It is really unrealistic for the majority of our youths to
aspire to become top-level professional athletes.
Furthermore, the top-level professional athletes as a group are not
the idols that our youths should emulate. The high salaries and endorsements
of top level professional athletes and coaches affect the pocket book of
ordinary citizens independent of whether they attend or watch any of the
sporting events.
It is clear
that the top-level professional athletes are not the ones who can help our
country to compete successfully economically in a world with global
competition.
Our society should
examine carefully our priorities, because the social implications are huge
in determining the characters and welfare of our children and grandchildren.
[2]
http://mlb.mlb.com/news/article.jsp?ymd=20080401&content_id=2479371&vkey=news_mlb&fext=.jsp&c_id=mlb.
[8]
http://wiki.answers.com/Q/As_of_2007_what_is_the_base_salary_for_an_Arena_League_football_player.
[10] There has not been much exposure
about NBA players, but the NBA has the weakest drug testing policy.
[13]
For a more detailed discussion of “Negative Versus Positive Media
Reporting,” see the article with this title in
http://www.dontow.com/Archived_PS_Articles/APS7-Media_Reporting.html.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Comments (or questions) from
readers are welcome.
Please specify whether you want to share your comments with only the author
of this website or with the other readers. If it is the latter, your
comments will be posted in the appropriate "Comments" page.
Please send them via an email to
[email protected].
Good Role Models for Our Youths to Emulate?